![]() |
![]() |
May/June 2001
Screen Version
The New ICE Age: TV Meets the Web
Madanmohan Rao reports from the Convergence Summit in Amsterdam
While the dot-com backlash is taking a heavy toll on the B2C front,
numerous start-ups are focusing now on another set of fronts on
the convergent infrastructure side: the convergence between the
Internet and telephony (dot-telecoms), the Internet and wireless
communication (m-dotcoms), and the broadband Internet and television
(broad-coms).
Over 240 delegates from 30 countries representing 200 companies
gathered in Amsterdam recently for the third annual convergence
conference titled "TV Meets The Web" (www.tvmeetstheweb.com).
"TV content on the Web has come a long way since the early days
of online Webcams and the TV clip of the Pathfinder landing on
Mars in the mid- 1990s," said Monique van Dusseldorp, CEO of pan-European
research firm Van Dusseldorp and Partners (www.vandusseldorp.com), which hosted the conference.
Players are approaching this interactive convergence from three
different sides: Internet companies, telecom operators, and media
players (TV and print). E-commerce is also being integrated with
television commerce or t-commerce as we enter a new ICE agewith
converged information, communication and entertainment sectors.
Music can be streamed well at 160 Kbps, half-screen video content
at 300 Kbps, and full-screen video at 2 Mbps. But in addition
to a good data pipe, key requisites for convergent ventures to
succeed include compelling content, interactive services, and
person-to-person (P2P) connectivity.
"It is very difficult to gauge what consumers may want or reject,
and the struggle for content providers in this austere times is
how to monetize their content and service streams. At the same
time, many entertainment companies are terrified of getting Napsterized,"
said van Dusseldorp.
There is also a huge flux in business plans as media players struggle
to find out what works and when, she said.
"This month's good idea looks like last month's disaster," said
Rob Shepard, executive vice president of interactive services
at UPC Media (www.upccorp.com), a leading broadband player in
Europe with offerings in broadcast and pay-per-view TV as well
as broadband Internet access and multilingual portals via its
subsidiaries like Chello and Priority Wireless.
"The broadband access market in Europe is expected to grow much
faster than the United States, but the growth will be steady and
not spectacular," Shepard said. "The key for interactive content
players is to deepen customer relationships and keep them consistent
across TV and PC channels," he said.
Adding interactivity to TV via two-way set-top boxes is being
offered by some operators by integrating online chat and SMS messaging
with TV programming; it works particularly well for offerings
like educational content (tutor interaction), game-shows (vote-along),
sports (statistics, choosing different camera angles), finance
(home-banking) and information inquiries (yellow pages).
The European market for interactive TV (iTV) is expected to reach
$3 billion by 2005, according to research firm Jupiter Media Metrix.
Europe has close to 1.5 million DSL and cable broadband connections,
expected to reach approach 20 million in year 2003.
"The future lies in integration of traditional and new media.
Synchronization of the two is the key digital proposition. But
to survive in today's climate requires focus and nerves of steel,"
according to Shepard.
"Unfortunately, there seems to be a lack of honesty or modesty,
maturity or clarity in the industry," observed Stuart Nolan, an
independent media analyst.
The land-grab phase of digital TV is now moving to a more sober
phase of increasing revenue per user (RPU) and profitability,
observed Robert Henderson, interactive TV analyst at NDS TV (www.nds.com)
in the United Kingdom, which has recently opened a development
office in Bangalore.
"There is now a new interpretation for B2C: back to cash," said
Brett Savill, director of financial advisory services at Pricewaterhouse
Coopers in London.
"We have evolved a new rule for development initiatives: if you
can't bill it, kill it," said Rafael Bonnelly, VP of content at
Terra Networks, the Internet wing of Spanish telecom Telefonica
which acquired the Lycos portal.
"We are now the No. 3 Internet company in the world, and are focusing
on an all-band strategy across all networks and sites with a mix
of free services on our search engine, registration services on
Tripod and Wired News, subscription for Terra Premium, pay-per-use
on Quote.com, and pay-per-view as with the Big Brother TV show
and Web site," said Bonnelly.
Telefonica is focusing not just on B2C Web and WAP portals, but
also the B2B market via new media consultancy and Internet data
center services, said Silvia Rico, investment manager at Telefonica
Media in Spain.
At the device level, a strong iTV player is U.S.-based Tivo (www.tivo.com),
which essentially offers set-top caches which store up to 60 hours
of TV content so that users can watch programs whenever they want
and also pause, rewind and replay movies in slow motion.
"Prime time in a world of personal video recorders (PVRs) is when
the user wants to watch TV, and is not defined by fixed broadcast
time slots," said Andrew Cresci, VP of Tivo UK.
Founded in 1997, the company claims that it sold more of its set-top
devices in the first 18 months of retail availability than VCRs,
CDs or PDAs did during each of their first 18-month periods.
"Tivo is a stable environment, and is friendly to everyone along
the TV and advertiser value chains," said Cresci. The company
has also forged a strategic partnership with AOL Time Warner which
is expected to extend service and marketing capabilities along
the Internet front.
Other European media conglomerates aggressively moving into broadband
Internet and iTV include the UK's Pearson Publishing and The Economist
magazine.
"We are moving from a content to an ASP model of broadband delivery
for areas like e-learning," said Keric Morris, director of strategy
at Pearson Broadband Education Television in London; over 80 percent
of Pearson Publishing's text books are now online, with a Web
companion.
The Economist magazine is extending its strong print brand to
the Net via a Web site (www.economist.com) and a TV site (www.economist.tv),
according to Tony Wales, director of Economist TV. The company
has formed alliances for airline in-flight programs and regular
TV content.
In addition to the TV and print players, innovative entry approaches
to consumer homes are being launched by mobile communications
companies like Nokia.
"There is a huge opportunity in integrating mobile communication
needs into the home environment," said Richard Nelger, head of
home product management at Nokia in Finland.
"The Berlin Wall in Germany came down over a dozen years ago,
and now the Berlin Wall between television and other channels
is coming down as well," said Nelger.
Over 20 billion short message service (SMS) messages were sent
worldwide in December 2000; 750 million were reported in the U.K.
In addition to being a leading global player in the mobile market,
Nokia is backing an initiative called Open Sources Terminal (www.ostdev.net)
to promote the creation of a media terminal for homes, based on
the Internet Protocol (IP) and Open Source components like the
Linux operating system, Mozilla browser, and HTML/Java.
"The key to integration of different channels is an open platform
for internet provider (IP)-based entertainment in the living room,
along with public collaborative development," Nelger said. Bluetooth
is expected to play a major role as a 'glue' for home IP devices.
"There is a real hunger out there for IP," said Jonas Birgersson,
CEO of Framfab Labs in Stockholm. But this will converge to the
content level, and not just to the access device level like cable
modems. IP television sets will soon open up a whole world of
programming to viewers, Birgersson said.
A leading Internet player in streaming content is Real Networks,
whose Real Player plug-in crossed the 200 million user mark in
April 2001, with 40 million in Europe alone.
"The economics of the Internet are real and profound, despite
popular sentiment. But making money online is more difficult than
expected. People will pay only for compelling content," said Joanna
Shields, VP at Real Networks for Europe.
85 percent of Web pages with streaming media reportedly use Real
Networks tools. The company has recently launched a Gold Pass
subscription service for premium content like music and videos.
For 'middleware' developers, huge opportunities are opening up
in content development and syndication, user authentication, customer
profile management, billing systems, set-top applications, ad
server systems, multi-channel content management platforms, data
centers, and systems integration.
European players in this space include X-CA.com and Mindport.com
(which outsources some of its pay-TV software development to India).
"The key to interactive broadband content like iTV lies with third
party developers," said Peter Larson, head of content services
at Liberate Technologies, which recently announced an agreement
with Sun Microsystems to extend Java technology to its set-top
boxes.
At the packaging level, extensible markup language (XML) platforms
can help content providers structure their offerings simultaneously
for Web, TV and mobile channelsreferred to by acronyms such as
CODE (create once, deliver everywhere) or COPE (create once, play
everywhere).
"All our news stories are created with headlines and summaries,
and are packaged and tagged in XML in three different formats
and speeds for the Web, PDAs and digital TV," said Barak Matzkevich
from the online video business development unit at Reuters.
Languages like virtual reality modeling language (VRML) have failed
due to inappropriate applications and an obsession with 3-D; Flash
has now emerged as the established broadband middleware platform,
according to Simon Birrell, CEO of Silicon Artists in Spain.
He also cautioned against too much emphasis on one-way broadcast-only
content, and stressed the importance of two-way as well as P2P
channels, though this raises challenges in ensuring quality, propriety
and monetization.
For content developers in a converged TV-Web world, an apparently
intractable issue involves reconciling the differing nature of
"lean backward and watch" nature of TV viewing with the "lean
forward and type" nature of PC interaction. Current iTV infrastructure
is also asymmetrically structured with a narrow up-channel as
compared to a broadband down-channel.
At the artistic end of the spectrum, one solution to keeping consistent
"brand carriers" across multiple channels is via animated icons
called avatars, said Stefan Kloos, managing director of I-Dmedia
in Berlin.
Such avatars can represent game characters, site guides, customer
care representatives, pop stars, sales agents, and newscasters,
said Kloos, whose company has created successful avatars for TV
and the Web like e-Cyas, E-Sha, and Sonya (for promoting the Sony
Vio in Europe).
Avatars can be easily scaled across online and offline strategies
in multiple languages, and do not entail messy negotiations for
artists' rights, he joked.
Another emerging sector of players on the Internet front is in
digital content delivery, by caching content closer to the 'edge'
of the network whereby interaction latency times can be reduced.
Companies in this sector include US-based Akamai (which has formed
partnerships in Europe with British Telecom and Spain's Telefonica),
Digital Island (recently acquired by UK-based Cable & Wireless),
and AstraNet.
"Content delivery network functionality will become a must-have
standard for telecom and media companies in broadband space. We
will see more pan-European players on this front," said Johan
Meulekamp, manager of Digital Island Europe.
Satellite operators will become major movers of IP-based multicasting
services for MP3 files and radio/TV streaming of microchannels,
according to Christian Schock, director general of SES Multimedia,
operator of European DVB/IP satellite service company Astra-Net,
whose Asia partner is AsiaSat.
As more and more information and entertainment content moves to
Internet formats, security and digital access management will
become paramount, and metadata will be increasingly merged with
data itself. Over 80 companies have also formed the Internet Streaming
Media Alliance.
"MPEG-4 has been chosen as the standard of choice for IP content
over next generation 3G mobile networks, and ensures vendor interoperability
as well as a digital rights management interface," said Ahmad
Ouri, general manager of Philips' MP4Net division in California.
"Most content will soon be delivered via IP. And IP content delivery
will eventually change the way content is produced, archived,
and consumed," Ouri said.
While much of this Internet-TV convergence has vast implications
for the entertainment and education industry, it has also caught
the eye of numerous governments and policymakers around the world,
who have launched broadband initiatives in partnership with the
private sector to gear up their citizens for the coming multimedia
explosion.
These include the Digital Island initiative (Singapore), Digital
Delta and e-City (Holland), Multimedia SuperCorridor (Malaysia),
Netville (Toronto), Cyberport (Hong Kong), Virtual Village (Helsinki),
and WiredUp Communities (UK).
"Public initiatives on the broadband front should supplement the
business models of industry. Benefits of city-based initiatives
should percolate to the rest of the country as well," advised
Philip Weinberg, a McKinsey consultant in London.
The writer can be reached at madan@inomy.com
Join the Internet Society today: http://www.isoc.org/welcome/